Attorney challenges sentencing disparities for young offenders in Sweden

Kristofer Stahre, an attorney representing a 15-year-old boy charged with ordering murders, is challenging a recent court ruling. He argues that there is a significant disparity in how courts interpret legislation concerning younger gang members involved in violent crimes. Stahre cites a May ruling, in which the Svea Court of Appeal sentenced a perpetrator to four years in secure youth care for three shootings. He emphasizes the inconsistency in sentencing, criticizing the reliance on the individual judge’s discretion rather than a standardized legal approach. “I want everyone to be judged equally under the law,” Stahre stated.

Helena Nordstrand highlights new provisions regarding particularly aggravating circumstances that can lead to harsher penalties. “Similar cases should result in similar sentences, but this case involves incredibly brutal acts, where a perpetrator entered homes and executed family members,” she noted, acknowledging that such actions affect the severity of the sentencing.

It is relatively uncommon for individuals under 18 to receive prison sentences, as youths aged 15 to 17 are typically sentenced to secure youth care for serious offenses. However, the government aims to change this policy. Plans are underway to replace youth care facilities with youth prisons, which are expected to be completed by summer 2026. Over the past year, several teenage boys have received longer prison sentences for gang-related murders.

Stahre insists that this case should be taken to the Supreme Court to establish a clear legal precedent. Nordstrand agrees, stating that guidance from the Supreme Court on how to assess penalties for young offenders is essential.